My take on toot
Since Ahmad first emailed me along with other bloggers announcing what could be called an early test launch of toot, and requesting opinions and feedback, I wanted to write about it, and review it, but soon after, it was taken offline, for further improvements and a couple of days ago, it was up again, but still in “not even alpha” according to the site.I am sure that the site still have a long way to go in terms of features and content, nevertheless, I will have my take on it anyway.
What struck me first, and many of those who I talked to about it, is the very nice interface and design, one could not expect less than that from Syntax which have some of the best graphic and UI designers in town. The other thing, is that the name “toot” is creative, meaningful, and colorful.
Now toot (according to thier About page) is a hand-picked aggregator, where best of posts, from the best of blogs from Arabia is selected. Now “what is best” is very subjective and arguable, but looking at the list of blogs they have, it seems that they did some initial research in the blogosphere hunting for blogs, and they came out with a very interesting initial blog list.
So far, although they have some Arabic blogs, the interface is still in english for some reason, there isn’t much information about the site in Arabic, as well, in the “tootreads” section of the main page, Arabic posts are shown left to right, rather than right to left (there should be some auto-detection code to make sections/posts that have arabic body “rtl” rather than “ltr” even in the english interface).
I wasn’t really able to understand the difference between “What’s tooting” and “tootreads”, is tootreads posts that were tooting before ? I wonder . Another thing, I would really like to see a feed (rss, atom) link for the “what’s tooting” or “tootreads” to be able to follow the blogs they feature from a feed reader/aggregator. As well, I wanted to submit another blog (not mine) and suggest it to toot, but it seems that the submit interface is oriented toward the blogger being the one submitting it, I would like to see a “suggest a blog” form to allow readers, and bloggers to suggest other blogs than theirs.
I am sure that there are still a lot planed for toot, one would expect a tag-oriented interface, as with the growth of the blogosphere, categorization and segmentation of featured blog posts will be a must. If toot continues to be a maintained, updated, and introduce proper arabic interface soon, I think that it will gain more and more exposure and success. With the growth of blogging in the Arab world last year, one could only expect it to grow even further this year. toot could play a role in making quality blogs and posts more exposed and featured.
thanks isam for this review. very valuable and true comments there. it’s feedback like that we’re seeking from the blogging community and readers alike, to help us determine where to take the site next.
anyway.. we have just put the site up on 1/1/2006 and I am happy to see that you have already visited it.. now the real works begins :)
i think its pretty brilliant and all the guys (and gals) who make it happen are wicked-cool :-D
of course i say this only because ive been deemed worthy enough to be hand-picked and listed there.
and also because its true.
oh and ahmad, u know the “im on toot” link-to-me images…it wud be nice to see them in the standard size as well
I really liked the idea of toot and the originality of it. But i have to agree with Isam about the subjectivity of “what is best” and “what is not”.
Also, i liked the idea of “suggest a blog” . This way we can have a great number of wonderful blogs.
Isam our wonderful critic and Toot guys, ya3teekom el 3afyeh.
When the name “toot” was tooted, did anybody toot that maybe toots just might after a short while get tooted of just the toot? Toot this, toot that, too many toot’s that one would even toot that the “too” in the beginning of this toot was just a spelling toot! Am I being toot negative here? Was this toot toot vague for all the toots reading? :p
Anyway, I think everyone did a toot job :=)
toot, Jeran, albawaba, Jordan Planet, Maktoob, Mahjoob, Jordan Net, Jordan Netseers, ……. I’m confused.
I agree with hatem, am confised too…..thiers too many blog community site, why dont we join forces in one place !!
For toot i think the deisgn is very creative it reminds me of ThinkMobi.com ;) not to forget the well prepared content, yet i guess Best Blogs is a bit relative as Isam said.
Good luck guys and excellent work
how about we realy think about joining forces together in one site for bloggers, guys we dont want to have a 100 sites all with the best posts ?!!
Great job guys… Thank for you work…